Skip to main content

A different kind of post

 I know this article is about 2 months old but I couldn't not comment...Carmen Reinicke writes in this article that "Raising the federal minimum wage to $15 an hour over time would boost paychecks and reduce poverty" (see article here: The US is closer to a $15 federal minimum wage after Biden win). That sounds great, right? Except for this...I currently make more than $15/hr and less than $20/hr. I am clearly not alone in this world. My income won't be raised as a result of this. I will actually suffer, along with millions of others. This will NOT reduce poverty. It will simply raise the poverty level to account for the higher pay. Think about it. If I go to the grocery store and every cashier and stocker and bagger makes $15/hr instead of $8 or $9/hr, how will the owner of that grocery store compensate for that huge increase in payroll expenses? One of two ways: lay people off and work with a skeleton crew which means the lines will be even longer and the shelves will be even barer, not to mention the cleanliness will decrease...or increase the cost of every item in the store...which may be fine for someone who went from $8/hr to $15/hr...but for everyone else it will be another added expense. This isn't just limited to grocery stores. This will be EVERYWHERE. 


Of course, the other thought that crossed my mind as I read this is that this mentality, trying to raise everyone to the same economic status, is a cornerstone for socialism. Now, I will not argue whether socialism is good or bad...it is just like any other political theory in that there is surely both good and bad. The issue is, though, that even those "wonderful" socialist countries that everyone goes on about as examples have some pretty discouraging characteristics such as the fact that "their citizens pay some of the world’s highest taxes" according to Robert Longley (see article here: The Differences Between Communism and Socialism ).


Just as another clarification, this is not a political post at all. I do think that something needs to be done in this country. I also think there is a large disparity between what type of assistance of any kind is available for someone who has almost no income to no income and someone who is working hard to provide for their family. I can say that for many years I worked very hard to provide for my family and times were tough. There were too many times to count when I was scared that the electricity would be disconnected or that we wouldn't have enough groceries for the entire week. I made less than those $15/hr then but more than the minimum wage too. And whenever I would get to the point where I would think it was time to apply for government assistance, I would be told that I never qualified for cash assistance to help cover bills and rent and rarely even qualified for food stamps. The most I ever received was $200/month and that was when I had four kids in the house (Ross's daughter, Josiah, Maria, and Ben). That did help, anything did at that time. But it was also a LOT of jumping through hoops and interviews and paperwork and everything else...and no consideration for the fact that I had to be working during the times when they would set up those mandatory interviews. And when I chose to quit working to stay home with my kids because they needed their mom during some pretty difficult times, I didn't qualify for any assistance - because I quit my job to be a mother. My heart goes out to those people. The ones who are worked to the bone and exhausted and feeling like no matter what they do they can never get ahead in life and to top it all off, they feel like failures at home because their kids aren't getting mom (or dad) time and the house is dirty and the laundry is piling up and dinner is whatever's in the freezer or some Ramen. 


Ok, well,,,I guess my rant is over now. As some sweet friends would like to point out my favorite saying, all that to say...before you jump on any bandwagon, do a little real research. Look at the big picture and think about ALL of the ramifications. Ok, well, probably not ALL of them or else we would all be economists and that job would get pretty stressful pretty quick. But still, there's always two (or more) sides to every story and there's always a bigger picture. 

Comments

  1. The last sentence is especially appropriate for discussing any controversial issue. Thanks, Rose.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Great Lakes Tour - Part 3

Welcome back to the final leg of our Great Lakes tour of 2018!  It has been such a blast to share these great vacation memories with everyone but I do have a disclaimer to add to this trip, and I probably should have included it in the other two posts as well. I may have cast Maria in a less than agreeable light during this trip. However, there was a good reason for it, even though at that time I only had slight suspicions. Maria was about two months pregnant with Giovanni at this time and was not feeling well at all, but was also trying to not let on about her "condition". So, with hindsight, I understand her crankiness. A side note to that disclaimer is that Ben is not mad in all of the pictures, he just tries intentionally to not smile in any picture. But no matter what, I still really enjoyed being able to take such a memorable trip with both of my youngest babies! So, lets wrap this trip up, shall we? Day 5: We packed up and began heading south through Ontario towards Ni...

The Great Lakes Tour - Part 2

  On my last post I shared about the first leg of our 2018 family trip. We affectionately dubbed the adventure our "Great Lakes Tour" because the plan was to visit all five Great Lakes in a single trip. After two days, we had visited our first lake - Michigan. In actuality, we also visited Lake Huron because that is the lake that Mackinac Island is on and Mackinac Bridge stretches over the Straits of Mackinac that are the convergence of Lake Michigan and Lake Huron. See...you're getting a geography lesson here too! However, I wanted to count each lake by taking photos of them from shores that I had not visited yet, or in the case of Lake Michigan, that I rarely ever visit. So Lake Michigan's photo was taken on its northern shore from the Upper Peninsula. Let's continue on with our journey, though, shall we? Day 3: Leave St. Ignace and head north to Tahquamenon Falls State Park. For me growing up, these were the most amazing waterfalls ever. Whenever anyone would t...

"All that to say..." Series!

 Ok, folks! I have decided that I enjoy reading things and then writing my thoughts down on what I read. That can be a book, a news article, an op-ed, a chapter in a textbook...whatever. So, since I am so entertaining (at least to myself), I thought I would share my thoughts with ya'll! Stay tuned here on this blog for upcoming "All that to say..." posts! And if you like what you read, please subscribe to the blog and share it with your friends. Also, comments are always welcome on any of my posts. I just ask that you act civilized toward one another...or I will prove to you that I am a mom and put you in time-out.  I know that some of my posts may ruffle political feathers of one side or another...or both. Also, I should add this disclaimer: If I post something that you do not agree with, there is no need to criticize my opinion or to unfriend or unfollow me or what have you. We can have civilized discussions about our difference in opinion. Comment your thoughts and I w...